Karen is very sympathetic and encourages Arthur that he can, and should, do better. Throughout Arthur's last moments fighting Micah he continuously bragged that he has won, contradicting Micah's claims that he had lost, because he successfully saved John and his family. She maintained her friendship with John years later. tbh I woulda plowed the shit out of Karen if I was in the gang lmao. Arthur and Hosea also went hunting for a Legendary bear, although they failed to kill him together, and they went fishing with Dutch where they shared anecdotes about their past together. She is the first to find and help Arthur after he escapes from Colm O'Driscoll and his men where he was tortured. The two grow close enough that Arthur feels comfortable to, for the first time, talk about his son and former lover, who both died after being murdered by two robbers over a petty amount of cash. During a random stagecoach robbery Micah Bell speculates that John could be turning on the gang and points out the doubts Arthur has of him, but Arthur retorts that hes known him for so long that he has no doubts, showing that, despite what John had done in the past, and how Arthur felt about it, he still knows John would never betray the gang. Whilst in Valentine, along with Uncle, Karen and Mary-Beth, Tilly is accosted by a gang member she used to be affiliated with, Arthur intervenes on her behalf and threatens the man, who leaves. The gang eventually escapes with the money. It is around this time that Dutch begins to negatively influence Eagle Flies to fight the U.S Army, to the worry of Arthur and his fellow gang member, and friend, Charles Smith. He can even talk to her about his illness, and his inevitable death, late in the game. Arthur would visit every few months and stay with Eliza and Isaac for days at a time. Trelawny arranges a plan to rob a lucrative riverboat called the Grand Korrigan, which is hosting a Poker tournament, and plays the role of getting Arthur trimmed and suited for the job and arrange his escort. After getting the dynamite for an upcoming heist Arthur tells John that whatever happens during the robbery, and wherever Dutch goes, he will get him the money he needs and get out of this life. Mary Linton is a good person. Arthur is aware of Micah's skills as a fighter and shooter, and Micah appears to respect Arthur for his shooting abilities in return, as well as saying that he finds it "fun" riding with Arthur. Sean was like the annoying younger brother to Arthur. In regard to Arthur's indefatigable ability to provide the gang with money, food, and supplies, Dutch, while encountered in camp, will call Arthur "the best man among us.". Arthur Morgan is the pinnacle of Rockstar's character crafting as he's more realistic than any character who has come before him. It was your third week with this group of people. Whilst at camp Javier can ask Arthur to find him some Oleander, and in return he will regularly leave throwing knives at his tent. On one mission, when rescuing Josiah Trelawny, Arthur gets himself captured by a bounty hunter and is being choked to death, the bounty hunter offers Charles money to leave and threatens to kill Arthur if he tries anything, however, Charles rather skilfully throws a knife at the bounty hunter, instantly killing him and saving Arthur. Arthur is very friendly with Karen and cares for her, this is shown early in the game when Uncle, Tilly, Karen, Arthur and Mary-Beth head to Valentine and whilst the girls scope the place out for information Karen takes a man to a hotel bedroom to rob him, but he starts to beat her. He will tell her how Arthur saved his life and that he thinks about him everyday, in response, she also reveals that she, too, thinks about Arthur a lot, showing how much she cares and respects Arthur before, and after, his death. In a random camp encounter Abigail complains that she cannot afford a new set of clothes for Jack, giving Arthur the choice to give her $5, indicating that he is willing to help Abigail and Jack in any way he can. Often times it gets my thoughts more organized too., Dont you write romance stories though? (Imagining the interactions that happen between them and the reader as they try to communicate would be funny ^^), A/N: This was very fun to write, because at some point, I too was a non-english speaking immigrant. This is first highlighted early in the story when Bill has the job of planting explosives when the gang intends to rob a train, however, the explosives fail to detonate and the crew is forced to improvise. There are things that can be forgot, and there are things that can be forgiven. requests are closed. Arthur, with Charles, then rescues Eagles Flies from Fort Wallace, much to Rains Fall's gratitude. Mary-Beth goes to Valentine with Uncle, Arthur, Karen, and . When he does tell her this she deeply sympathizes with Arthur but she will also try to reassure him, and tell him he still has time to do good. During Arthurs final confrontation with Micah, and the few remaining gang members, John unexpectedly appears and sides with Arthur, revealing Dutch left him to die. However, Trelawny is very useful and a pleasant person to be around. If you've never been a relationship where you both love one another but just can't make it work because you aren't quite compatible then you won't really get it. s more fun to have a character say what Im thinking. Honestly that shit was god damn real as it gets if you've been there. They escape into the forest and the gang splits up, with Arthur going with Uncle. She touches her tongue to the fine droplets of wet blood that coat her lips and cheek; it tastes of earth and salt, like the faraway memory of sea spray. Arthur pitied Swanson's proclivity for drunkenness. He was often quick to point out this poor habit and the foolish situations he got himself into, forcing Arthur, at one point, to save him from getting killed by an oncoming train after he gets his foot stuck in the tracks. The fight ends with Sadie killing the O'Driscoll's last leader and opening up to him about how much she misses her husband. However, Arthur was captured by the O'Driscoll Boys and was briefly tortured by them, having escaped and arrived back at camp, Dutch was clearly relieved at his return but also apprehensive about the dire state Arthur was in. Congratulations, Abigail. They also pulled jobs together, such as robbing the bank in Valentine and stealing a wagon full of weapons and explosives from the Lemoyne Raiders at Shady Belle, it was because of this job that the gang knew of Shady Belle and could use it as their next camping spot. Arthur interacts with Mary-Beth, where the two share anecdotes of their past, before Miss Grimshaw comes up to Arthur to tell him that Tilly has gone missing. Arthur is also willing to take part in Bill's plans, like robbing the bank in Valentine. Fanfiction. Gets easily irritated, but always the first one to apologize. He tries to give Jack advice and, at the request of Abigail, asked if he wanted to go fishing with him. She asks if its too late for them to have a future together and asks if they could run away together. Uses very bad, cringy, pick up lines. Please consider turning it on! If John visits her in the epilogue, she will again express gratitude for Arthur's actions, his help having enabled her to survive and live happily. Abigail Roberts.Arthur Morgan.John Marston.Three people.Two who have been in each others' lives for what seems like forever.One who came in and changed everything.Highs and lows that seemed lower than possible.No matter what though, no matter what will happen in all three of their lives,they'll be there for each other. Wont go into any discussion, too much spoilers. Despite this, Arthur keeps a picture of him next to his bed over two decades later and also wears his hat, hinting at some measure of fondness. He enjoyed joking around with Arthur, for example whilst in Saint Denis Dutch snook up on him and held him at gun point, much to his amusement. It was Trelawny's intel that helped the gang locate Sean after he was captured in Blackwater following the failed job there. This is their story. . Something Abigail deeply appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jack's sake. Favorite Arthur/John/Mary-Beth headcanons? Nonetheless, the interactions we do see shows that they are good friends with great respect for each other. Dutch, who turned back to get him, tells Arthur that he could not find John and that he is either dead or has been captured, with Arthur being visibly devastated from the news. Eagle Flies was apprehensive and skeptical of him and believed he was nothing more than a hired hand who only worked for the highest bidder, and had no real care for the well-being of his people. Pearson is usually upbeat and kind to Arthur and he returns the favour. Abigail is saddened when Arthur is forced to part ways with her and Sadie because he has to confront Micah. Abigail is one of the gang members that Arthur can play Dominoes with at camp. A lot of people don't know, but Mary Beth and Kieran are most likely into each other. What little shred of faith and loyalty Arthur had left for Dutch had finally been broken. So if you wanted to picture Arthur and John in handsome military uniforms, then this is the story for you! A/N: This was probably the easiest request for me to do because I go to sleep imagining this everyday. Arthur leaned against a nearby tree, clutching a beer in his hand. The Pinkertons then arrive at the gang's hideout and a shootout begins, John and Arthur flee through a cave and up a hill, where Dutch, Micah, Cleet and Joe begin chasing them. By the end of the chapter, Arthur is in a stand off with Micah andinformseveryone in the gang that he is the rat and has been helping the Pinkertons. At camp Hosea is one of the gang members Arthur can play Dominoes with. Johns last words to Arthur are we're brother's, which Arthur responds by saying I know, I know.. Favorite Arthur/John/Mary-Beth headcanons? This is quite frankly a place for me to just collect anything I write for this little rare-pair. When Micah Bell arranged for Dutch and Colm O'Driscoll to parlay Dutch showed complete trust in Arthur protecting him from a distance with a sniper rifle. Summary: Based on this request: Can I get one where Arthur reacts to hearing you sing at camp for the first time? Under the assumption that Jack had lost John, Arthur ran off with Sadie to rescue Abigail to prevent Jack from becoming an orphan. He decides to leave the gang and, should Arthur not help the nun in Saint Denis, will meet Swanson at the train station after dropping off Captain Monroe. Summary: Mary Beth want to confess her feelings for you, but she's nervous. He also taught Arthur how to read, along side Dutch. Boy has all the dexterity of his father before him, but he still managed a better job than Uncle who was on the bottle before I could get him working. Arthur glanced back but kept following Sadie as she held onto his hand with a death grip. Whilst confronting Milton Arthur is told by him that Micah has been informing the Pinkertons about the gang's activities. John took Arthurs words to heart of running and not looking back, as he used those words on Abigail and Jack before his own sacrifice. Should the player accept, Arthur will attack the ranch. On the way back to camp they were bushwhacked by the Lemoyne Raiders. What if Arthur stepped in to help raise Jack and take care of Abigail? To the frustration of Dutch who says that his "doubting" makes him soundlike John. The relationship Arthur has with other characters can be dictated by the actions of the player, for example, the player is given the choice to talk to various gang members whilst at camp in either a positive manner or a negative one. Arthur loved his son and remembered Isaac fondly as being "such a good kid." The experience hardened him and made him realise that he doesn't deserve the kind of happiness that his now dead family once gave him because of the life he leads. I thought that's sweet, don't you?". However, Arthur would reassure Lenny that he has friends and that he should not try to impress everyone in the gang because the people that matter (himself, Dutch and Hosea) are aware of the effort he puts in. It mightve been fourth or maybe even fifth, but you couldnt tell. She is sixteen and he must be twice that. So, without any further ado, send your head canons, imagines, and fanfic requests my way! Despite this it is hinted by Tilly, in a letter to John, that Karen drank herself to death. Abigail had to know if this was Arthur seeing how useless John was and just taking pity on her and Jack, or if he was feeling the same way she had been lately. Mary-Beth Gaskill just didnt have the same ring to it as Leslie Dupont. Started in Jan 2021 Enjoy. If not thats totally okay!! Jack can ask Arthur to get Abigail's Thimble and a Penny Dreadful book, showing he goes to Arthur when he is in need of something, in return for the Thimble he will give you a drawing, for the book he will regularly leave Candy Bars at Arthur's tent. Whilst at camp Arthur treats Jack with great care and affection when talking to him. Arthur first meets Eagle Flies along side his father, Rains Fall, in Saint Denis. She is ultimately killed by Micah when she is caught off guard by Javier shouting that Pinkertons are on their way. Mickey liked Arthur as he states that he was his only friend. He becomes grateful for Arthur rescuing him and starts to believe he genuinely cares for his people. After Hosea died, Arthur said he missed Hoseas wisdom. Mary-Beth liked the name Leslie because it was ambiguous, both male and female and Dupont Well, French had always seemed so romantic to her. Loves running her fingers through your hair. He stepped cautiously along, barefoot, and murmuring to himself. There are mature themes peppered in here, so just a fair warning. Molly will tell Arthur that she broke her pocket mirror and is worried it will give her seven years bad luck. They find two of Cornwall's men and go to stealth kill them, only for Uncle to fumble it and Arthur is then forced to save him. Trelawny says he hopes to meet Arthur again but Arthur doubts this as he expects to die soon from his tuberculosis. He admits that he respected Arthur once before, but he now considers Arthur, along with John and Charles, traitors and hopes they get whats coming to them. Sean, the bastard thats dragged him along that evening, skips past him to sit in the booth behind her. Bill is shocked when he sees that Arthur is losing faith in Dutch and tells Arthur, whilst robbing some dynamites in Van Horn, that he believes he has gone soft.